Budget 2011: Multinationals cause tax headache
Big corporations are fleeing Britain's tax regime and George Osborne has to work out how to encourage firms to stay - and pay. City Focus by Simon Duke.
Dilemma: Osborne faces delicate balancing act
Faced with the largest peacetime deficit on record, George Osborne is preparing measures aimed at stemming the exodus of big companies from these shores.
Tomorrow's Budget is likely to herald a far-reaching overhaul of rules governing how much tax multinationals pay on profits they earn overseas.
At stake is the £47bn that firms are forecast to pay into state coffers in the coming financial year - equivalent to around 8% of total tax receipts.
Even for accountancy wonks, the Controlled Foreign Companies (CFC) rules are an obscure and dusty corner of the tax code.
But impenetrable as they are, the CFC rules are a growing source of rancour between the Government and big business.
The CFC code was originally conceived to stop more companies from bypassing HMRC by channelling all of their profits through subsidiaries in low-tax jurisdictions.
But over recent years, a number of big British firms, including advertising giant WPP and pharmaceutical group Shire, have shifted their tax residence to Dublin, where the corpocity residence to Dublin, where the corporation tax rate is just 12.5%
Building materials group Wolseley and publisher Informa have set up camp in Switzerland, with Luxembourg and the Netherlands among the other popular destinations for footloose multinationals.
It is not so much the rate of tax that is pushing companies towards the exit. Despite regular protestations from big business, Britain is not an especially high tax economy.
According to the Oxford Centre for Business Taxation, the UK corporation tax rate is the lowest in the G7 and has been 'well below' average for the past 25 years.
Instead, it is the way foreign earnings are taxed that has made Dublin, Zug and the Hague such powerful magnets. Under current rules, firms must pay the UK exchequer the difference between Britain's 28% corporate-tax rate and the profit charge levied on its foreign subsidiary (provided it was lower).
Without this rule, it would be all too easy for companies to avoid much more than a peppercorn rate of profit tax. For instance, a British company could route profits through foreign subsidiaries in countries with lower rates of tax.
But, increasingly, these principles are coming under attack with nations 'racing to the bottom' in a bid to lure big corporations. Ireland, for instance, has abolished tax on foreign earnings for multinationals, which have to do little more than set up a brass-plate operation to exploit the rules.
The advantages for corporate refugees are clear. WPP, which is domiciled in Dublin for tax purposes and incorporated in light-touch Jersey, has reduced its corporation tax rate from 26% to 22% over the past five years. Based on last year's £850m profits, its 'continuing tax planning initiatives' have reduced contributions to the taxman by £34m.
Although so far only a trickle of companies have jumped ship, Osborne could conceivably be dealing with a flood as Diageo, Reckitt-Benckiser, HSBC and Barclays have all threatened to move.
But the Chancellor faces a delicate balancing act. Were he to follow Ireland's lead, he'd effectively be giving the green light to wholesale tax avoidance, making the task of tackling the deficit more Herculean still.
Mike Warburton, at accountancy group Grant Thornton, said: 'The Chancellor has a big hole to fill but he's not going to do that if more multinationals leave.
'But it's important that we have CFC rules. There has to be legislation to avoid a leakage of tax.'
Instead of dismantling the CFC legislation, it is likely that the Government will perhaps cut the rate of tax charged on overseas profits.
Following the 'corporate roadmap' published by the Treasury in the autumn, Osborne could also introduce exemptions on profits from intellectual property and, crucially, exempt a large portion of overseas 'finance income' from corporation tax.
Many UK-based multinationals are already bending the rules by setting up financing subsidiaries in low-tax jurisdictions.
Profits are funnelled through these 'treasury' divisions, and are subject to lower rates of tax when the cash is moved back 'on shore'. Richard Murphy, director of Tax Research UK, fears that tomorrow's Budget will 'legitimise' these 'grey areas'.
The opportunities for major corporations to avoid 'significant amounts of tax' are likely to 'proliferate' over the coming years, he argued.
Not only will this dramatically increase the burden on ordinary workers, but it also creates even more obstacles for smaller companies, which generally don't have the know-how or resources to exploit tax loopholes.
Most watched Money videos
- Skoda reveals Skoda Epiq as part of an all-electric car portfolio
- Fiat pledges to cease grey car production as they launch new EV
- BMW meets Swarovski and releases BMW i7 Crystal Headlights Iconic Glow
- 'Now even better': Nissan Qashqai gets a facelift for 2024 version
- Tesla unveils new Model 3 Performance - it's the fastest ever!
- Mercedes has finally unveiled its new electric G-Class
- How to invest for income and growth: SAINTS' James Dow
- 2025 Aston Martin DBX707: More luxury but comes with a higher price
- Land Rover unveil newest all-electric Range Rover SUV
- Blue Whale fund manager on the best of the Magnificent 7
- Mini Cooper SE: The British icon gets an all-electric makeover
- Mini celebrates the release of brand new all-electric car Mini Aceman
- Avon Protection handed £38m gas mask contract by MoD
- Cameron left red-faced as Greensill sues Government over...
- Will my newly self-employed husband cause us a remortgage...
- Two in five believe ovens will become obsolete as the air...
- Bailey pulls his punches on interest rates yet...
- BUSINESS LIVE: UK GDP grows 0.6%; IAG profits take off;...
- Watches of Switzerland buys Italy's Roberto Coin Inc for...
- ITV hit by Hollywood strikes as it pins hopes on Euros...
- BBVA goes directly to shareholders as it steps up bid for...
- Ford confirms it will cull another of its best-selling...
- Why we need more than a British Isa to move the dial on...
- Mortgage rates are climbing again - should we be worried?...
- Used car sales hit a five-year high as fresh supply of...
- ITV hopes for summer ad boom as it continues to reel from...
- Vodafone told to boost security as £15bn Three merger is...
- MARKET REPORT: North Sea giant Harbour closes in on £9bn...
- Private chauffeurs, spa days and more independence: How...
- Bank of England paves way for Britain to cut interest...